How to Find Out What Kind of Fiction I Like: A Simple Guide to Discovering Your Reading Preferences

Not sure what kind of fiction truly speaks to you? This post explores simple ways to discover your favorite fiction genres, from reflecting on past reads to trying new storytelling styles—helping you find books you’ll genuinely love.

5/10/202510 min read

person picking white and red book on bookshelf
person picking white and red book on bookshelf

How to Find Out What Kind of Fiction I Like: A Simple Guide to Discovering Your Reading Preferences

Discovering personal preferences in fiction can feel overwhelming with the sheer variety of genres, styles, and authors available today. The easiest way to find out what kind of fiction you like is to sample different genres, pay attention to your emotional responses, and reflect on what types of stories keep you interested. This process doesn't require expert knowledge—just curiosity and a willingness to explore.

Many readers begin by considering what movies, TV shows, or stories they have enjoyed in the past. Patterns often emerge, whether that's a love for character-driven plots, fast-paced thrillers, or imaginative fantasy worlds. By noting which themes, settings, or characters they naturally gravitate toward, anyone can narrow down their favorite types of fiction.

Understanding Fiction Genres

Fiction genres help readers narrow their preferences and guide them toward stories that match their interests. Knowing the distinctions between genres, subgenres, and current trends allows readers to make informed decisions about which books to try.

Overview of Popular Fiction Genres

Fiction is divided into several major genres, each with its own defining traits. Mystery centers on solving crimes or uncovering secrets, with clues and suspense driving the narrative. Science fiction explores technology, space, and speculative futures, often questioning how advancements affect society. Fantasy features magic, mythical creatures, and imaginary worlds, drawing readers into realms beyond reality.

Romance focuses on relationships and emotional journeys with plots built around love and attraction. Historical fiction sets stories in the past, blending research with imagination to bring different eras to life. Horror seeks to evoke fear and suspense, using supernatural elements or psychological tension. Other genres include thriller, literary fiction, and adventure, each offering unique story structures and themes.

Difference Between Genre and Subgenre

A genre refers to a broad category of fiction, such as fantasy or romance, defined by common themes, settings, or elements. A subgenre is a more specific classification within a genre, adding distinct twists or targeted topics. For example, detective fiction is a subgenre of mystery, while epic fantasy is a subgenre of fantasy.

Understanding subgenres helps readers find books that align even more closely with their tastes. For instance, someone might prefer historical mysteries (a mix of mystery and historical fiction) or dystopian science fiction (a subgenre of science fiction). Awareness of subgenres can prevent disappointment by giving readers clearer expectations about what a book offers.

Genre Example Subgenre Mystery Cozy Mystery Romance Romantic Suspense Science Fiction Space Opera Fantasy Urban Fantasy Horror Gothic Horror

Emerging Trends in Fiction

Recent years have seen the rise of cross-genre fiction, where boundaries blur between established types. Books may blend romance and horror, or mix fantasy with real-world settings, appealing to readers seeking something new or unique.

Diversity in characters and settings is increasingly important. Many new works focus on marginalized voices or underrepresented cultures, expanding the range of available stories. Serialized fiction and interactive storytelling, often distributed digitally, attract readers who prefer episodic or immersive experiences.

Some authors experiment with formats, such as novels told through text messages or social media. This reflects how technology shapes not just what stories are told, but how they are structured and shared.

Identifying Your Personal Interests

Personal reading preferences are influenced by past positive experiences, exposure to storytelling in various forms, and the specific emotions certain stories evoke. Paying careful attention to these patterns helps clarify which types of fiction are likely to be enjoyable.

Reflecting on Past Enjoyment

Readers can gain valuable insight by recalling books or stories they have enjoyed in the past. Identifying recurring genres, authors, or themes is useful. For example, someone who remembers loving mystery novels as a child may still appreciate the puzzle-solving element in fiction today.

A practical way to organize these reflections is to create a simple table:

Title Genre Memorable Element "The Westing Game" Mystery Plot twists "Pride and Prejudice" Romance Witty dialogue "Dune" Science Fiction World-building

Noting what stood out about these experiences—was it the world, the characters, or the plot—reveals important preferences. This method can include not just books, but stories from school, family, or personal experiences.

Analyzing Your Preferences in Other Media

Preferences often extend across different types of media. Many readers find patterns in their favorite movies, TV shows, video games, or podcasts. The type of stories enjoyed in these formats can point directly to preferred themes, moods, or genres in fiction.

For example, enjoying science fiction films or fantasy video games might indicate a taste for speculative fiction. People who favor gritty documentaries may prefer realistic or historical novels. Listing the genres and themes found in favorite shows or games helps highlight what resonates.

Analyzing story elements, such as a love for strong characters or a preference for fast-paced action, also reveals trends that can guide fiction choices.

Recognizing Emotional Responses to Stories

Noting how particular stories make a person feel can clarify which fiction will be most satisfying. If a reader notices they are deeply moved by stories about friendship or loss, books with these themes are likely appealing. A preference for feeling excited or tense suggests a draw toward thrillers or suspense.

A practical approach is to write down emotions experienced during or after reading or watching a story, such as:

  • Moved to tears by a character’s journey

  • Energized by a fast-paced plot

  • Comforted by humorous writing

Patterns in these emotional responses make it easier to predict which types of fiction will bring the most enjoyment. Exploring why these emotions occur can point to specific story elements such as tone, themes, or character relationships.

Exploring Different Types of Fiction

Discovering personal fiction preferences involves reading a variety of forms, styles, and time periods. Exploring multiple options makes it easier to recognize patterns in enjoyment and interest.

Sampling Short Stories and Novellas

Short stories and novellas are effective entry points for fiction readers. They allow sampling of many genres and authors without a major time commitment. Collections such as The Best American Short Stories or anthologies focused on genres like science fiction, mystery, or romance provide quick exposure to diverse voices.

Short forms often feature concise storytelling, unique premises, and experimentation with themes and structure. Readers can try multiple authors in less time than it takes to read a novel. Using library apps or websites like Project Gutenberg gives access to classic and contemporary short works for free.

Paying attention to which stories make a lasting impression can reveal recurring traits or genres that consistently appeal. Creating a simple list or table to track favorite stories, authors, or themes may clarify patterns of interest:

Title Author Genre Rating (1-5) "The Lottery" Shirley Jackson Horror 5 "Hills Like White Elephants" Ernest Hemingway Literary 4 "Story of Your Life" Ted Chiang Sci-Fi 5

Trying Different Writing Styles

Fiction comes in a range of writing styles, from straightforward prose to more experimental or lyrical language. Some authors use minimalist, dialogue-heavy techniques, while others prefer descriptive and ornate passages.

Sampling authors with contrasting approaches—such as Raymond Carver’s spare realism versus Gabriel García Márquez's magical realism—gives a sense of what style resonates. Focus on how different styles affect comprehension, engagement, or emotional response.

Readers may notice preferences for fast-paced plots over introspective narratives, or vice versa. Annotating passages that stand out due to voice, description, or pacing helps identify what feels most engaging. Keeping notes on specific likes and dislikes related to writing style can guide future reading choices.

Comparing Classic and Contemporary Works

Reading across time periods helps pinpoint preferences for language, themes, and settings. Classics such as Pride and Prejudice or 1984 offer familiarity with historical context, distinct dialogue, and a window into the concerns of their era. Contemporary fiction often addresses current issues and reflects modern language and sensibilities.

A side-by-side comparison can highlight differences in pacing, character depth, and structure. Some readers may appreciate the slower build and formal style of older works, while others prefer the immediacy and relevance of newer stories. Exploring award winners from each era, or using lists like the Booker Prize and Pulitzer Prize for newer fiction, provides structured starting points.

Testing both classic and modern works in genres of interest can determine whether appeal is rooted in the time period, subject matter, or narrative techniques. Taking notes on reading experiences and revisiting previous favorites after sampling a range may further clarify what types of fiction are most appealing.

Using Tools and Resources to Narrow Your Selection

Readers can identify their fiction preferences by exploring interactive assessments and leveraging digital recommendation platforms. These options provide tailored suggestions and help clarify which types of stories align with their tastes.

Taking Online Quizzes and Assessments

Online quizzes and assessments can highlight preferred genres, themes, and styles. Tools such as What Should I Read Next?, BuzzFeed quizzes about book types, or the Literary Taste Test ask targeted questions about favorite story elements, characters, or past reads. Some of these quizzes use personality metrics, while others rely on direct questions about reading habits.

Quizzes often include questions like:

  • Do you enjoy fast-paced or slow-building stories?

  • Are you interested in historical settings or modern worlds?

  • What is more important: character development or plot twists?

Results often present a list of genres—such as science fiction, literary fiction, or fantasy—and sometimes recommend specific authors or book titles. While not foolproof, these assessments can give readers a starting point when feeling overwhelmed by choices.

Using Book Recommendation Platforms

Book recommendation platforms use algorithms, tags, and community reviews to match readers with books that suit their interests. Sites like Goodreads and StoryGraph allow users to rate books, create lists, and input preferences. These platforms then analyze this data to suggest titles that align with demonstrated tastes.

Features to consider:

  • Personalized suggestions based on user profiles

  • Curated lists such as “If you liked X, try Y”

  • Community ratings and in-depth reviews

  • Search filters for genres, moods, and tropes

By customizing settings, readers can zero in on fiction that matches their mood or curiosity. Recommendations update as preferences evolve, making it easier to discover new favorites.

Joining Communities for Recommendations

Connecting with others who share a passion for fiction can introduce new genres, authors, and titles. Feedback from peers and like-minded readers helps refine personal taste and discover books that are often missed by algorithms or bestseller lists.

Participating in Book Clubs

Book clubs meet in person or online to discuss selected titles, often on a monthly basis. This provides structured opportunities to explore different styles and voices, especially as group members take turns choosing books. The discussion format encourages participants to think critically about what they enjoy or dislike in a story.

Some clubs focus on a certain genre, such as science fiction or historical fiction, while others cover a wide range. Members frequently share personal recommendations and insights, making it easy to build a reading list with novels similar to previous favorites.

Benefits of book clubs include:

  • Exposure to lesser-known works

  • Direct conversations about themes, plot, and writing style

  • Motivation to finish books and keep reading regularly

Joining a club often leads to discovering authors and genres that would be overlooked when reading alone.

Engaging with Online Forums and Social Media Groups

Online spaces provide forums for discussing every aspect of fiction, from niche subgenres to popular series. Websites like Reddit, Goodreads, and dedicated Facebook groups allow readers to ask for recommendations based on specific preferences, such as tone or pacing.

Interaction is often more flexible compared to a book club. Readers can join discussions, read reviews, and explore lists at any time. Many groups sort content by genre, making it simple to focus on areas of interest.

Key activities include:

  • Posting questions or polls about favorite books

  • Reading user reviews and curated lists

  • Participating in themed reading challenges

These communities offer a wealth of firsthand experience and opinions that help narrow down the vast world of fiction to a personalized selection.

Evaluating and Reevaluating Your Choices

Preferences in fiction can shift over time, making regular assessment valuable. Being deliberate about tracking experiences and staying open to change helps readers discover what truly resonates.

Keeping a Reading Journal

A reading journal gives a structured way to keep track of what an individual reads and how each book is received. By briefly noting impressions, favorite parts, disliked elements, and specific themes or genres, readers collect data that reveals patterns.

Key details to record may include:

Book Title Genre Rating (1-5) Memorable Aspects Dislikes Example Book #1 Science Fiction 4 Fast pace, world-building Unresolved ending Example Book #2 Mystery 5 Clever twist, strong protagonist Slightly slow beginning

Reviewing these notes after every few books surfaces repeated likes or dislikes, such as a preference for plot-driven stories or character-focused novels. Short journal entries make the process quick and sustainable.

Reassessing Your Preferences Over Time

Interests change with exposure, life stages, and experiences. Revisiting past reading lists a few times a year can reveal new trends or fading interests in certain genres.

He or she might notice a renewed interest in classics or a shift toward non-fiction narratives. Occasional self-assessment—through questions like Was this book fun to read?, Do I want more of this genre?, or Did my favorite author change?—helps update personal preferences.

These recalibrations can guide book selections going forward. If patterns of enjoyment shift, it's practical to adjust reading lists, library holds, or wish lists accordingly. This approach ensures fiction choices continue to align with personal tastes.

Addressing Common Challenges in Discovering Fiction Preferences

Some readers encounter specific hurdles when searching for fiction they enjoy. Mindsets about genres and the sheer amount of available choices are two key issues that can make the process difficult.

Overcoming Genre Stereotypes

Genre stereotypes can lead readers to avoid entire sections of fiction, missing out on stories they might enjoy. For example, someone might think all science fiction focuses on space battles, or that romance novels are always formulaic. These generalizations overlook the variety within each genre.

A good approach is to explore subgenres. For instance:

Genre Subgenre Example Distinct Features Science Fiction Dystopian Social commentary Fantasy Urban Fantasy Real-world settings Romance Historical Romance Period-specific drama

Trying short story collections or anthologies can introduce unfamiliar genres in a low-commitment way. Reading reviews or sample chapters often helps to identify unexpected appeal. Readers can focus on themes, character development, or settings that attract them, rather than the label assigned to the book.

Dealing With Decision Fatigue

The number of fiction choices available can be overwhelming. Decision fatigue may cause readers to stick to the same kinds of books or give up searching altogether.

To narrow down options, readers can:

  • Use recommendation lists tailored to specific moods or interests.

  • Pick award-winning books in different genres.

  • Ask friends or use online forums for personal suggestions.

Limiting the number of choices per session—such as reviewing three book descriptions at a time—can help make the process manageable. Setting small goals, like selecting one new author per month, relieves pressure and encourages variety. Keeping a simple log or using an app to track preferences makes future selections easier and more confident.

Expanding Your Horizons Beyond Your Comfort Zone

Readers often gravitate toward genres and authors they already enjoy. While this can be comforting, sticking only to the familiar may limit discovery of new favorites.

Trying different genres helps readers figure out what appeals to them most. For example, someone who enjoys fantasy might also find magical realism engaging or appreciate the suspense in a well-crafted thriller.

A practical approach is to use the following strategies:

  • Sample first chapters from different genres before committing to a full book.

  • Join a book club that occasionally picks genres outside personal preferences.

  • Rotate reading lists to include one unfamiliar genre every few months.

Familiar Genre Try This Unfamiliar Genre Mystery Science Fiction Romance Historical Fiction Fantasy Literary Fiction Thriller Young Adult

Library staff and independent bookstores often provide recommendations based on reading history. Tools such as book-swapping programs or reading challenges can also prompt exploration without much risk.

By seeking out unfamiliar story types, readers increase their chances of identifying previously overlooked interests. This gradual exploration makes it easier to recognize what kinds of fiction genuinely connect with them.